34 users responded in this post

Subscribe to this post comment rss or trackback url
mygif

I’ve got to question the Dr. Octopus logic. I agree that his background makes a great ‘reverse-peter’, but has he ever been in a really good story?

ReplyReply
mygif

Darkseid would scoff at Thanos for having been so obsessively in-love with Death, because that adoration made Thanos a slave to Death–where Darkseid serves no one but Darkseid.

Also, why no Vandal Savage?

ReplyReply
mygif
Lister Sage said on June 3rd, 2008 at 2:42 pm

I want to know which Captain Marvel your talking about. I assume DC, but I want to be sure.

ReplyReply
mygif
Andrew W. said on June 3rd, 2008 at 2:52 pm

Darkseid also has the benefit of being voiced by Michael Ironside.

ReplyReply
mygif

I’ve got to question the Dr. Octopus logic. I agree that his background makes a great ‘reverse-peter’, but has he ever been in a really good story?

The one I always cite is from an annual, where Ock breaks out of prison unexpectedly, robs a blood bank and a shipment of radioactive isotopes, and we intersperse scenes of Spiderman hunting him down with flashbacks of Ock as a child.

It’s a very, very well-done story about what, exactly, Ock is planning to do with what he’s stolen, and why. And it’s perfectly in keeping with his megalomania, all along.

ReplyReply
mygif

I’m still wondering at Akane Tendo. Ranma was a much more entertaining character with lasting appeal.

He was the first jerk-ass character that I really liked, mostly because his adventures were so far out there (and there were enough spectators around to point out how strange it all was, even after they got used to certain aspects of that life) and even at his most angsty there were still two or three jokes per page to dispell that atmosphere.

ReplyReply
mygif

I dunno man, the guy wants to topple the fascist state and create anarchy. That’s quite straightforward. You could argue all day about whether there is a death wish there as well, but I don’t see that there is much going on behind the mask. Compare Rorschach who would have also been just an enigmatic “badass” without his demasking at the end of Fearful Symetry.

Evey, Finch and Mr. Susan speculate about V’s motivations and so does the reader, but ultimately he’s more important to the reader in how he effects the really rounded characters in the book than in any intrinsic qualities of himself. Enigma is perhaps the better word than cipher, but I don’t believe that there is a solution to the riddle, and a riddle without a solution is just a deliberate head fuck.

I would have put Finch in V’s place – because if we’re being perfectly honest with ourselves he’s probably what most of us would turn out like under a fascist regime and he choses to liberate himself, rather than needing to be bullied into it by V.

ReplyReply
mygif

Not that this is a criticism of V for Vendetta you understand. The book wouldn’t have been nearly as brilliant if we’d have had anymore humanisation of V than we got. This is why the film wasn’t nearly as good, when Hugo V says that he loves Evey we know what he means, when comic V says he loves Evey it’s anyone’s guess as to whether he means romantically, paternally or just because she’s becoming a mirror of him.

ReplyReply
mygif

Agree 100% on Darkseid, Scrooge McDuck and Deadpool though. Green Goblin has a cool gimmick with the glider and the pumpkin bombs but I think his biggest fanboy would struggle to argue he wasn’t Dr. Luthor and Mr. Joker.

ReplyReply
mygif
Ken Raining said on June 3rd, 2008 at 3:45 pm

You find Nexus wildly overrated? That’s it, we’re not friends any more.

Of course, to be fair, if I made a list like this myself, I would have had to make the same comment about Transmet and why Spider Jerusalem isn’t on my list.

ReplyReply
mygif

I guess I should through out a nomination for Richie Rich if only because he was my first introduction to comics (well Richie Rich and G.I. Combat.. nice mix huh)
Deadpool to me always seemed like a one trick pony.. I like him as a character though so I can’t argue the point.

I guess Scrooge would be a better choice than someone like Super Goof.. or better, the Phantom Blot who I think is the one of the best comic villans ever

ReplyReply
mygif

has Ock ever been in a really good story?

Doctor Octopus: Year One.

Owes a debt to that Ron Lim story John mentions, sure, but is really really really quite good.

//\Oo/\\

ReplyReply
mygif

Btw, MGK…what do you think of this list:

http://goodcomics.comicbookresources.com/2008/04/18/the-top-100-comic-book-runs-master-list/

And what’re your top runs?

ReplyReply
mygif

You make a good point, re: Hillary’s supporters, but I think perhaps you miss how personal this campaign is for them. Every time another prominent blogger or Obama surrogate issues another attack on Clinton- and it happens 3-4 times a day, especially if you look at a site like AmericaBlog or something- they take it personally. And while there’s a part of me that thinks they need to grow up and accept that their candidate lost a long time ago, I can’t say that I wouldn’t be equally frustrated and feel equally alienated if the circumstances were reversed. Because it does no good to keep attacking Clinton once she’s lost; it just creates a redundant loop, in which Clinton says something questionable, Obama supporters attack her, Clinton supporters get offended, and the whole thing remains acrimonious.

Now, we can’t make Clinton stop saying questionable things. But since she’s not going to be the nominee and Obama is, we don’t really need her to do that. We -can- control whether or not we further alienate her supporters by letting even the desperate nonsense coming from her campaign make us angry enough to attack her. Since that doesn’t benefit us anymore (unlike, say, when she had a shot at swinging enough superdelegates and her ‘kitchen sink’ strategy was a threat), the only thing that comes of it is pissed off Clinton supporters. Because on top of everything else, they’re a very passionate group who just lost a close race, and that sucks for them. Arguing that she’s stupid and should have quit months ago doesn’t bring them over to our side. What I really mean to say is that, as the winning team, we have the power to end the fight. Let them mourn the death of this particular dream without reminding them over and over that we hate their candidate, and they’ll come around. They have to.

–d

ReplyReply
mygif
lance lunchmeat said on June 3rd, 2008 at 7:01 pm

If you need any, I have every issue of Rex the Wonder Dog’s original run. I also have his Secret Origin and “Whatever Happened to Rex the Wonder Dog?” in which he becomes functionally immortal.

ReplyReply
mygif

I’m surprised that anyone would even question the presence of Scrooge McDuck on an all-time greatest list. If anything, he should be in the top 10 in my book!

ReplyReply
mygif

I get what you’re saying about Darkseid; my only quibble would be that the very fact that he’s comfortable with his own evil makes him a character who can’t progress in any meaningful fashion, and (to me) those are always less interesting than characters that do. Darkseid is never going to be anything other than what he is right now, whereas Thanos constantly surprises me.

I’m not saying Darkseid isn’t a good character…just that he probably slips below “Top 50” for me.

ReplyReply
mygif

Deadpool to me always seemed like a one trick pony.

Then you haven’t read him as written by Joe Kelly.

ReplyReply
mygif
Tom Galloway said on June 3rd, 2008 at 8:22 pm

Not just Barks on Scrooge; the Don Rosa stories are also excellent (and I’m something of heretic for prefering them over Barks, certainly in Rosa’s own eyes, but he’s got the advantages of building on the great foundation from Barks and I think more consciously writing stories with appeal to adults as well as kids). I highly recommend Rosa’s Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck, where he takes pretty much every mention by Barks of something in Scrooge’s past and puts it all together. There’s a companion volume with additional set in the past stories as well. But it’s all excellently done; I’m particularly fond of the two Scrooge / Teddy Roosevelt team-ups.

ReplyReply
mygif
Bill Burns said on June 3rd, 2008 at 9:07 pm

I think TAO belongs somewhere in the top 60-70, maybe higher.

ReplyReply
mygif
Chris Russell said on June 3rd, 2008 at 9:54 pm

Kudos to John. I think the Dr. Octopus blood bank heist story is one of the triumphs of Spider-Man (granted, I’ve only read maybe 300 single issues). The background story really drives home the “opposite of Peter” trope that MGK mentioned, and the bitter obituary writer is a great framing device.

ReplyReply
mygif
Chris Russell said on June 3rd, 2008 at 9:54 pm

That story wasn’t in an annual, by the way, it was Spider Man Unlimited #2 or #3.

ReplyReply
mygif

Most of the reasons for Doc Ock being Spidey’s greatest villain have already been listed, but I’d like to throw out one more. Doc Ock was the first villain to ever truly beat Spider-Man. Spidey eventually took him down, but his first confrontation with Ock was an unqualified loss, and it shook him to the core.

ReplyReply
mygif

While I love Ock a great deal-Sinister Six and Master Planner storylines rate as, IMO, some of the best ‘classic Spidey’ ever, The classic Goblin is really unbeatable for just how much and how deeply he hurt Pete in issue 121…

ReplyReply
mygif
Zenrage said on June 4th, 2008 at 1:07 am

Darkseid stopped being interesting to me when I realized just how much power they’ve given his omega beam over the years. At this point, I’m wondering why his Omega energy hasn’t gained its own sentience and left Darkseid blind and visionless.

ReplyReply
mygif
Required Name Here said on June 4th, 2008 at 2:07 am

wow, good call on the whole “what else BESIDES hillary for pres?” and the response of “hillary for pres!” i didnt realize that really was their entire platform. it is all personality, yes. in reality, didnt mean disenfranchise, but you finished it in the solomon one.

and what dan solomon said a couple comments above mine.

ReplyReply
mygif

Thinking about Scrooge, I recall an episode of DuckTales where he quested for a folio of lost plays written by an Shakespeare equivalent (“Drakespeare?”) because one of them was rumored to be “MacDuck” and he was convinced it was a story written about one of his ancestors. He went to a ton of trouble, teamed up with/encountered a troupe of actors, and eventually found the plays.

And then he saw the acting troupe perform MacDuck, and was aghast when he realized that the titular character, who he believed was based on not just his ancestor but his family’s progenitor, was not just a skinflint, but a cheat and a crook.

I can’t remember how it resolves, but I want to say the actors explained that it was just a story, just a name–and that if Drakespeare had known Scrooge the play would’ve been much, much different. I thought it was pretty cool, when I was a kid.

There was also one where Scrooge became an out and out superhero using a nifty purple costume and a cane that could do some neat tricks. That one was pretty cool too.

ReplyReply
mygif

…Following up one long-winded post with another post. Go me.

The thing about Darkseid is, as Jack Kirby concieved of him, he is a god. The New God of Evil. The Great Darkness. One of my personal favorites is from “Rock of Ages,” where he’s referred to as “The Rock and The Chain and The Lightning.” Of course, in “Rock of Ages” he was also killed by Connor Hawke and Ray Palmer, which I didn’t like so much, even though I like both of those characters quite a bit.

He hasn’t been overpowered. More often he’s been DEPOWERED by writers who want his gravitas but need him to lose, or just don’t get it, or both (this happened a lot during the 90s). The Omega Effect is how Darkseid’s divine power expresses itself, so when he radically changes somebody, kills or resurrects them, or just hurts the holy hell out of them, it’s not a power added in–it’s something he could do from day one. It had its limits, of course–he doesn’t have real omnipotence or omniscience; that’s why he lusted after the Anti-Life Equation for so long. There’s a difference between being a god and being God.

One thing Darkseid is noted for doing very, very often is killing off his underlings when they irritate him and resurrecting them when he needs them, with full knowledge of the experience of being bitched and full awareness that this is Just The Way Things Are Because He’s Darkseid–and YOU AREN’T.

There’s all sorts of alternate stuff in there depending on who’s writing him. In the X-Men/Titans crossover from the 80s Darkseid noted that children are instinctively aware of his presence, while adults tend to unconsciously edit him out of their perceptions.

“Adults deny me, but children know me for what I am.” That’s the line. Implying, of course, that Darkseid is the thing in the dark that humans are instinctively afraid of, the thing that was so terrifying they harnessed fire to ward it off–which is either lame or really cool depending on who you are and whether or not you’ve had your coffee.

Ultimately, as a concept, Darkseid is meant to be an elemental, primordial evil – a Great Enemy. A lot of writers have failed to grasp this and fallen woefully short of the mark–hell, Peter David Did Not Get It–Grant Morrison seems to, but Grant Morrison needs to drop acid to grasp ideas Jack Kirby conjured up on reflex.

It makes him less knowable than Thanos, and certainly less empathatic; but all the more scary for his eloquence and wit. An ultimate evil with both a grasp of the Big Picture and an eye for detail. I think Lovecraft would’ve looked at the Darkseid character concept and rethought all the tentacles and the rising from the seas. But that’s just me.

ReplyReply
mygif
CandidGamera said on June 4th, 2008 at 9:14 am

Feh. Ambush Bug is an archetypical character who stands, by himself, in contrast to the entire stable of every comic book superhero ever. He’s the iconoclast. Wade just likes Bea Arthur.

ReplyReply
mygif

“While I love Ock a great deal-Sinister Six and Master Planner storylines rate as, IMO, some of the best ‘classic Spidey’ ever, The classic Goblin is really unbeatable for just how much and how deeply he hurt Pete in issue 121…”

Yes and no. It’s true that Norman hurt Peter in a way that nobody had since the mugger, but that’s pretty much the ONLY thing he did prior to the “OH! He’s really still alive and magically responsible for the Clone Saga!” retcon.

Until recent years, Otto Octavius has been more of a thorn in Peter’s side than Norman Osborn could ever dream of. MGK is absolutely correct when he says that Otto, not Norman, is the dark mirror.

ReplyReply
mygif

Cogent political discussion and Scrooge McDuck — this post has everything.

ReplyReply
mygif

FWIW, my favorite Scrooge McDuck issue was when he discovered that the royal land grant for his vault predated American independence, so he declared sovereignty and demanded that the government return umpteen-bazillion dollars in illegitimately-paid taxes.

Then the town cut off his electricity and police protection because they weren’t authorized to deal with foreign nations, and so the Beagle Boys just walked in, took over, and declared themselves dictators. Donald wanted to mount a coup, but Scrooge decided to give in and rejoin the union.

That was the best comic ever. Ever.

ReplyReply
mygif
santoleri3 said on June 5th, 2008 at 7:18 am

See, I would have put in Dredd. What I find problematic with this list is the example of Yorrick AND 355, Rorschach AND the Comedian, Or Tulip AND Cassidy. They come from great, but self contained, stories. Where Hawkeye, Luthor, Spiderman, etc. are going to remain interesting wherever they are. Which is why I would have Nightwing here. Brilliant call on Scrooge McDuck. I picked up a couple… guess they must have been reprints or something, for my son a few years back. I went back into his comic pile and fished it out to read one after I read your explanation. Brilliant.

ReplyReply
mygif
EvilAbrahamLincoln said on June 5th, 2008 at 8:31 pm

Doctor Octopus vs. Green Goblin? You gotta be kidding!

Norman Osborn was a fuck-up with delusions of grandeur. Otto Octavius was a respected scientist.
Norman Osborn ran a business which was failing before (and possibly) after his exposure to the Goblin serum. Otto Octavius almost took over New York City, then gained a pair of unbreakable tentacles.
Norman Osborn had two insanely ineffectual personalities. Otto Octavius, excluding his arachnophobia phase, has always been depicted as being as calm as a midnight breeze.
Norman Osborn, killed with his own glider. Otto Octavius, killed _someone else_ with his malfunctioning arms.

Bottom line, Norman Osborn’s current status in the Marvel Universe is a result of some sort of twisted, “Spider-Man needs his own Lex Luthor. Who can we get?”, mandate. Pre-death, Osborn was a failure as a businessman (The fucking _Molten Man_ ran Oscorp with more skill than he did), a father (“Oh great, my son overdosed on drugs! Maybe I should knock up one of his distaff classmates from his first year of highschool!”, and a scientist (A perfume designer {trained in biochemistry, but still…} was the first person to produce a Goblin serum that _didn’t_ result in flat out insanity). And Doc Ock? He’s just the guy who’s held Spider-Man’s life in his hands on multiple occasions, has killed more people _accidentally_ than GG has killed with intent, and he was banging Aunt May for the sheer pleasure of knowing that Peter couldn’t do anything about it without spilling his secret.

ReplyReply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please Note: Comment moderation may be active so there is no need to resubmit your comments