36 users responded in this post

Subscribe to this post comment rss or trackback url
mygif
Cookie McCool said on February 7th, 2008 at 1:52 pm

I’ve never personally picked up a copy of a Legion comic book, so when I start reading one of these features, I always think, “Hey, these sure sound like interesting stories, I can see why he digs it so much.” And then, about halfway though, I realize, “Holy shit, he just MADE THAT UP. It is not actual comic book canon, like it completely plausibly sounds. My bad.” I really wish someone would wake up and hire you already, because I really these ideas, and I’d love to be able to read them. I find myself forgetting that Civil War didn’t go down the way you wrote it, and was in fact a retarded stupid thing.

ReplyReply
mygif

Please to make Batbots look like Terry from Batman Beyond.

I am a sad little man with strange needs.

ReplyReply
mygif

Lucky duck, My algebra teacher blocks computer access during class.

ReplyReply
mygif

Is there anything that can’t be improved by a time-traveling Batman?

ReplyReply
mygif

Onions.
And maybe Ribs.
Oh and soy sauce!

ReplyReply
mygif

That’s beautiful. And creepy. It’s creepy beautiful!

ReplyReply
mygif

Do you suppose a bat-bot would pretty much HAVE to look like it couldn’t possibly be real? I mean, these are people who whom bat-like creatures aren’t just normal, they could be your neighbours.

What does THAT set of cowardly and superstitious people find creepy and scary? And does the WAYN3 actually care, or does it do the bat just because that’s what you do when you’re a hideously crippled Batman psyche?

ReplyReply
mygif

That is quite simply awesome.

ReplyReply
mygif

I do have a couple questions:

when W.A.Y.N.-3 returns, will he be at the head of a team based on the Outsiders or the JLA? I mean, after all, the records clearly show that when Batman defeats a superhuman menace it’s using one of his groups of superhuman lackeys….

Also, will Babbage be featured?

ReplyReply
mygif

If you don’t tweak that to an actual proposal and get it into the hands of DC editorial, (even if taht takes a top-secret ninja mission) I’m going to…well, I’m going to cry. Or steal the idea, whichever.

ReplyReply
mygif

For christ’s sake, someone should hire you already. There is more love and amazement and genius in these ideas that there are in the entire output of DC Comics in any given month.

ReplyReply
mygif

I wonder if the people who actually write legion, (past, present, and hopefuls of the future) or are responsible for it at least, are taking your ideas and filing them away to use at a later date. Hell, I wonder if they plan to use your ideas in OTHER comics.
I mean, its not like you can sue them for ripping you off. And these are just awesome story ideas. I mean, just AWESOME.

ReplyReply
mygif

I haven’t commented on any of these if-I-wrote-the-Legion ideas up until now. Which is out of character, as anyone who clicks my name will no doubt discern. It’s not that I liked them or didn’t like them (although I do like some and don’t like others as much); it’s just that… well, anyone can come up with ideas, but not everyone can write a good story.

But what I do like is that you have a specific *take* on the Legion in mind, much as Mark Waid did, Jim Shooter seems to, and Geoff Johns may or may not have, and that’s what’s a) indispensable, and b) missing from a lot of nostalgists who want the old-style Legion back but don’t have any details past that.

ReplyReply
mygif

All Wayn-3 needs is an avatar to run around the streets in true iconic fashion to confront and defeat these pesky Legionaires.

Say.. don’t you have a Bat-Pire running around this timeline somewhere?

ReplyReply
mygif

Imagine WAYN-3 trying to figure out the Legion. I imagine the process would go thusly:

–Colorfully-clad superbeings are violating the laws. (Even if the LSH has official sanction, WAYN-3 wouldn’t know that)
–Therefore, they are not just criminals, but super-villains.
–Super-villains commit large, public crimes and are the largest threats to the city.
–Before committing large, public crimes, super-villains leave taunting clues tied to their motif.

Therefore:
–Find the taunting clues this army of super-villains has left.
–Decrypt.
–Intercept super-villains to prevent super-crime based upon decrypted clues. This is the primary mission, to supercede all others.

This could be both scary and hilarious. What would WAYN-3 consider the Legion’s Riddler-esque “clues?” The upside-down rocket headquarters? The flight rings? And what super-crime would these “clues” suggest, at least to a bizarre pseudo-Batman of the thirty-first century? String them together and it spells…what?

Karate Kid and Matter-Eater Lad versus an army of Robot Whirly-Bats would rule. I’m just sayin’.

ReplyReply
mygif

I just imagined the legionaries fighting a swarm of Batbots inside an underground complex.
An the average Batbot says “I . AM. BATMAN.” 20 times per minute.

Thank you, it was glorious.

ReplyReply
mygif

Time-travelling Batman is just like time-travelling Wolverine: Just. Say. No.

This brings to memory an episode of Batman: TAS (maybe it was a two-parter), where something similar happened. Some dude created a supercomputer who would replace people with robot duplicates. They made a copy of Batman, and Batman and Bat-robodoppleganger fought in the batcave. Batman eventually won by convincing the Bat-robodoppleganger that the robot had killed him. The robot just couldn’t cope with it, based on Batman as his persona was. I guess the explicit imperfection of W.A.Y.N.-3 makes that sort of thing (or similar tactics) futile.

ReplyReply
mygif

This is a magnificent, perfectly thought-out jewel of a storyline.

Why you are not currently being paid vast sums of money for this by DC I’ll never know.

ReplyReply
mygif

Okay, this has nothing to do with the substance of your post, but…

Class was cancelled! Due to snow! YOU GO TO OSGOODE, WHICH IS AT YORK! I graduated from York in April, AND IN THE FOUR YEARS I WAS THERE I NEVER ONCE HAD A SNOW DAY!

I am jealous. Bastards.

ReplyReply
mygif

Andrew: You’re thinking of HARDAC, right?

ReplyReply
mygif

2/7/2008: Chris Bird wins the internet.

Awesome idea sir, each one of these notions astounds.

ReplyReply
mygif

Except for the possible time traveling Batman, I love the idea. In a title like Legion, if you have to get a guest star to help solve the problem, it detracts from the heroes of that title.

Also, if one of the batbots was left over after WAYN-3’s eventual dismantling, so it could scream “MY PARENT IS DEAD”…that’d rule.

ReplyReply
mygif

I will point out that, as awesome ideas as they are, and they are pretty damn good, a bit too 20C-bound for my tastes, but surely full of possibility: Ideas are cheap. Editors won’t hire someone for their ideas; they hire ’em for their ability to write good scripts on deadline.

ReplyReply
mygif

As I’ve said before, under a different penname, in various ways, Bird’s ideas make me believe that superhero comics can be great again.

And Mr. Morrow: good ideas are the basis of good scripts. Ideas are cheap – great ideas are not.

I renew my call that some of the artists who read this blog contact Mr. Bird about working on a comic project together. This could demonstrate Bird’s ability to translate his ideas to sequential art.

ReplyReply
mygif

Hot DAMN, this is brilliant. I want this to happen right now. Kudos, sir.

ReplyReply
mygif
CandidGamera said on February 8th, 2008 at 9:41 am

Well, it beats throwing a new rebooted version of Computo at them.

ReplyReply
mygif

Sharp. Very sharp. One question: Have you read Adam Warren’s Titans: Scissors, Paper, Stone? That could almost all fit together, rehabilitated in the end…

ReplyReply
mygif

I am contemplating a time-traveling Robin, and I’m enjoying that contemplation.

ReplyReply
mygif

Mr. Carter: I will also point out that C-Bird’s Reason #35 isn’t a story; it’s a back-story. Again, not something an editor is likely to base a hiring decision on, because it’s not going to get published.

If I were the LSH editor, I’d’ve interrupted the pitch at about four different places to ask him to tell me a story about the Legion.

ReplyReply
mygif

I gotta say, I came here because of the CIVIL WAR parody (brilliant) – but dammit.

I don’t care for the Legion at all. I never ‘got’ it. They’ll have a guy who can eat test tubes or bounce on the team over a kid who can control plants and make them grow (he can cure famine!!!). “Karate kid”.

Yeah. No.

But I’m reading these.

Hand on heart – I WANT TO READ THESE. I will, for the first time ever, pick up a Legions comic even though Adam Hughes didn’t draw it. I want to read them.

This one in particular – as it got to the end, it was pure gold. Then you said, “If you expected a time-travelling Batman to help…” and I thought, “Nah, don’t go for that trope”, you went and said, “You may be correct” I geeked out. So my inner nerd wants it, and who am I to argue with me?

There’s one thing – one thing only: I don’t get why the place would be called Gotham in any way (Gothcorp, Gothplex, Gothopolis, what-have-you). If Gotham is an amalgamation of many cities, then surely, it would be named after the most enticing one, not the one renown for being filled with crazy evil. Surely it should be called Anywherebutgothamcitypleaseweneedtouristsplex. Or something. Then, when it’s revealed it use to be Gotham, the nerd bends can strike. Or maybe not. Maybe there’s some ridiculous plot line in Legions and DC history that means it HAS to be Gothtown or whatever. I suppose, “It’s where Batman came from” but since he’s, at times, an urban myth in his own lift time, why would people remember him 1000 years later?

Answer: unknown by me. Also – unimportant.

Your pitch is stellar. I want to read the comic.

ReplyReply
mygif
Katzedecimal said on February 17th, 2008 at 7:45 pm

It has to be said… “My programmers are dead!!”
There. I said it.

ReplyReply
mygif

Onions.
And maybe Ribs.
Oh and soy sauce!

Bullshit, time-traveling Batman would improve every single one of those things.

ReplyReply
mygif

Oh, but stuff would get published Greg – this random Bat Computer AI doesn’t just appear from the ether, it has to come from somewhere. If “The Legion fights a robot Batman army controlled by an AI designed to simulate Batman” doesn’t count as a Legion story, well I don’t know what does

ReplyReply
mygif

It actually hurts me this isn’t a comic. I would read this until it fell apart in my hands, and then I would weep.

ReplyReply
mygif
Soylent Robot said on April 26th, 2010 at 6:23 pm

WAYN3 needs a J0K3R

ReplyReply
mygif
Raven Reed said on February 5th, 2012 at 9:38 pm

WAYN-3’s creators, perhaps in the only way they had been able to before they were put in suspended animation, could have injected a virus in the programing. I don’t know what the J-0 K-3R would stand for, but something akin to a random generator but with a sense of humor. It could certainly be interesting.

And to reiterate what several people have already said, I would read these comics in an instant, and I’m fairly new tot he Legion fandom.

ReplyReply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please Note: Comment moderation may be active so there is no need to resubmit your comments